The EHC has five member societies:
- Jewish Historical Society of Greater New Haven, founded in 1976
- Italian-American Historical Society of Connecticut, founded in 1979
- Connecticut Ukrainian-American Historical Society, founded in 1983
- Connecticut Irish-American Historical Society, founded in 1988
- Greater New Haven African-American Historical Society, founded in 2003
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/86931/86931b7f4335a2283cff49306bc9a74c087cf705" alt=""